Barry Ritholtz is one of my favorite market-focused bloggers; he has the rare ability to balance quantity and quality. This week, with the 10-year breaking the key psychological level of 5%, a lot of people are asking what that means for equities.
Barry offers six reasons why rising bond yields pose a (potential) problem for the continuation of the bull market:
1) Valuation: Models such as the so-called Fed model that have been declaring equities undervalued rely on comparing the earnings yield with the 10 Year yield. As the yield spikes, what was "undervalued" by this measure suddenly is much less so.
2) The M&A / LBO Put: One of the firm bids supporting this market has been the manic pace at which public companies have been taken private of by Private Equity (soon to be public themselves). Some have argued this was based on cheap stock prices, but we shall soon find out that it was based in fact on cheap money. As that goes away, so too will the LBO Put.
3) Competition: If you could get a guaranteed 5.5% or 6% on your money -- risk free -- would you? The answer depends on your personal situation, but for many institutions and wealthy investors, the answer is absolutely.
4) Profits: If it costs more to borrow or finance, that bites into profits. Indeed, this has been one of the primary complaints about the Fed model, it double counts low rates this way, and can makes apparently cheap looking companies more expensive-looking in fast order as rates rise.
5) Share buybacks: Much of the share buybacks we have seen have been financed with cheap borrowed money. This is another leg of the bullish stool that is about to leave town on the same stagecoach as low rates. (cue music, sunset)
6) Consumer spending: With MEW sliding, we have seen an increase in consumer credit driven spending. Watch that crimp if rates stay near 5.25%. Indeed, we could see a move towards 5.5% by Summer's end once people realize Bernanke is serious about a rate hike by year's end.
I don't necessarily agree with Barry's bearish conclusions (more specifically, the timing of his conclusions), but he gets the risks right. I'm more of the mind to side with ISI's Francois Trahan, who argues that we've got historic levels of liquidity throughout the financial system and that has, historically, been great for the equity markets when it coincides with rebounding LEIs. Record cash levels on corporate balance sheets, healthy interest coverage ratios, a global glut of broad money supply are just a few reasons not to waive the white flag...yet.
barry ritholtz bond yields risk factors investing francois trahan woodrow
Comments